This is a review of the best 5-cup coffee makers. Read on and find something you won’t regret buying.
I built this list of 5-cup coffee makers to help folks who drink such a large amount of coffee daily have a more convenient machine.
I chose the Zojirushi Zutto as the best overall because it’s from a highly reputable company, doesn’t cost too much, and is beginner friendly.
You may not love the price as much as me. I’ve provided plenty of cheaper alternatives. Some which offer more features.
Let’s jump in.
7 Best 5-Cup Coffee Makers for Home Use
- Zojirushi Zutto: Top pick
- Cuisinart DCC-5570 5-Cup Coffeemaker: Best budget pick
- Krups Simply Brew: Best for beginners
- Capresso 5 Cup Mini Drip: Includes auto shut off
- Bonavita 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker Machine: Best with thermal carafe
- Mr. Coffee 5 Cup Programmable 25 oz: Has reusable filter
- BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffeemaker: Best maker, Canada
7 Top 5-Cup Home Coffee Makers
All the 5-cup coffee makers mentioned are drip coffee makers with varying carafe materials.
Drip coffee makers are automatic pour-over machines. You insert a filter and beans, press a button, and water will spray over your beans.
From there, the coffee drips into the carafe while extracting flavor from your beans. Carafe type matters too. I’ll cover more details on it in the buyer’s guide. But in short, thermal/stainless steel carafes retain heat better. And glass provides a window to see your remaining coffee.
Let’s jump in.
1. Zojirushi Zutto: Best Overall
The Zojirushi Zutto is ideal for solo coffee enthusiasts who appreciate a minimalist aesthetic and a perfect fit for small kitchens or office spaces.
It’s worth depends on the user’s priorities and appreciation for its specific strengths.
Every Zojirushi product I’ve owned has outlasted its warranty. Yours can too. So long as you take care of it, regularly clean and descale it, and don’t slap it around.
It’s not wide, so it’ll fit in small kitchens, recreational vehicles (RVs), tiny homes, and studio apartments. So long as you have plenty of vertical clearance or an exposed area like a table to move the machine too.
You must access the water reservoir by opening the lid in the back. From there, you’ll need to remove the tank or hover a pitcher over it to refill. This seemingly easy task will become stressful if you have low-hanging wall cabinets.
Unlike most coffee makers, you won’t need top access to reach the coffee filter slot. It’s built into the carafe, which I wish was stainless steel instead of glass. Because it would be less fragile and keep drinks warmer for longer.
I also wish there was an auto-on button or programmability. However, the lack of all these buttons makes this an ideal entry-level drip coffee maker. It’ll last a long time, it produces great-tasting coffee, and it’s pretty easy to maintain.
2. Cuisinart DCC-5570 5-Cup Coffeemaker: Most Affordable 5 Cup Coffee Maker
The Cuisinart DCC-5570 is a perfect match for those who appreciate a quick, quiet brew and a clean pour.
Considering the quality, space-saving design, and convenience, the Cuisinart DCC-5570 is worth the price.
This is one of the thinnest machines I’ve seen, making it ideal for small kitchens without much counter space. It’s a double-edged sword, though.
Because they put the power button on the machine’s side, which makes it much more difficult to access in some scenarios. For instance, if you surround your coffee maker with other appliances.
I don’t know why they’d put the button on the side, not the front.
If you have a counter with many appliances, how are you supposed to reach the button and the water reservoir without moving the DCC-5570? And when moving it, be careful. Despite having a stainless steel body, many of the components on the body are plastic.
It won’t withstand wear and tear well.
Keep your coffee warm for 30 minutes after brewing with a warming plate. Afterward, the thermal carafe will retain that heat for another couple of hours. Great for sipping on drinks throughout the day.
3. Krups Simply Brew: Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker for Beginners
The Krups Simply Brew is a perfect match for the solo coffee drinker who appreciates a quick, quality brew without the fuss of pods.
Weighing its performance and the quality of brew it delivers, the Krups Simply Brew is indeed worth the price.
Simply Brew’s reusable filter prevents you from wasting money on continually buying paper filters. But it isn’t so great for those who use fine grinds. As tiny grinds will often lodge themselves into the mesh.
Or those grounds could get into your drink.
However, such fine grinds are only necessary for anyone who loves black coffee with a strong taste.
It doesn’t work with coffee pods. The same goes for any coffee maker in this list.
The biggest thing that bugs me is the machine’s design. While it’ll fit on countertops without much space, it’s a pain to access. You need a lot of vertical clearance to access the water reservoir and filter.
And once the tank’s full, you have to look on the machine’s side to know its level. How would you see it on a countertop stuffed with other appliances?
The Simply Brew’s hotplate will keep your coffee warm so long as you keep it on. Don’t keep it on there for too long. Leaving it on a hot plate for over 30 minutes may result in it burning your coffee and leaving burn marks on your carafe.
What’s the Pause & Serve function?
Say you’re scratching at yourself because you haven’t had coffee in 8 hours. And your coffee maker’s mid-brew with 1 out of 5 cups brewed. Rip that carafe from the machine, fill your cup, and satisfy your craving.
Afterward, return the carafe and it’ll resume brewing.
A bit unnecessary. But I suppose this function just doesn’t appeal to me.
4. Capresso 5 Cup Mini Drip: Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker With Auto Shut Off
The Capresso 5 Cup Mini Drip is ideal for those living in smaller spaces or leading a minimalist lifestyle.
Considering its price, the Capresso 5 Cup Mini Drip is worth it for those who value simplicity and functionality. Despite its smaller size, it offers programmable features and a permanent filter, providing a convenient and economical coffee brewing solution.
Here are the features it offers:
- Programming: Set a time for the machine to power on.
- Reusable filter: Eliminates need for paper filters.
- Compact: Fits well in small kitchens.
- Warming plate: keeps coffee warm for 2 hours; then powers off.
Many folks claim the warming plate won’t keep coffee hot for 2 hours. If this worries you, get a coffee maker with a thermal carafe. Regardless, the paper filter, low price, easy-to-access controls, and programmable auto-on are excellent.
And since it’s a low-cost machine, it likely won’t brew per SCAA standards . If you care a lot about your coffee’s taste and temperature, keep shopping. If not, this coffee maker’s ideal.
This next pick will keep your drink warmer for longer. Without a warming plate.
5. Bonavita 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker Machine: Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker With Thermal Carafe
The Bonavita 5 Cup is a perfect match for the meticulous coffee enthusiast who appreciates precision and consistency in their brewing process.
Considering its high-quality build, consistent performance, and the precision it offers in brewing, the Bonavita 5 Cup is indeed worth the price.
I’d list the Bonavita as the number 1 choice if it wasn’t so expensive. The biggest factor that contributes to its price is its Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) approval. That signifies this machine passed various tests and met the SCA’s criteria.
This criterion includes ideal numbers in the following categories :
- Extraction rate: It should extract the flavors from 18-22% of the coffee weight in the basket
- Temperature: 198-205 °F
- Brewing time: Between 4 & 8 minutes.
- Carafe temperature: Should stay around 176-185 °F for the first 30 minutes
- A good user manual: Must provide useful information.
The last point may sound unimportant, but it makes an enormous difference when learning how to use and clean a machine. If you make mistakes because of misreading a poorly written manual, your machine may not last as long as you hope.
Plastic parts of this machine may not last long due to not withstanding wear and tear well. And the carafe lid is a pain to clean due to being difficult to keep it open. However, those don’t sway my overall opinion of this machine.
The lack of programming and other features do. Many other SCA-approved machines include the ability to set it to brew at a specific time. Or temperature/brew strength control and pre-programmed brew types.
One could argue the lack of these functions improve accessibility to beginners. I agree. All the “SCA Approved” coffee I had blown everything else I tasted out of the water. It’s flavorful and worth every penny.
Whether you want to lose the “advanced” features depends on your needs.
Stop wasting money on paper filters with our next recommendation.
6. Mr. Coffee 5 Cup Programmable 25 Oz: Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker With Reusable Filter
The Mr. Coffee 5 Cup is a perfect match for solo coffee enthusiasts or small households where a single person needs a caffeine fix. Its compact size and programmability make it a great choice for dorm rooms or office cubicles.
Considering its price point, the Mr. Coffee 5 Cup offers good value. It’s a reliable machine that delivers hot coffee consistently, and its programmable feature adds convenience.
It’s an affordable machine that offers programming. Meaning, you set the machine to brew later. For instance, set it to brew coffee when you wake up and get ready for work. Then you’ll have a fresh cup of Joe.
But it can make a lot of noise. You’ll need to gauge whether this machine will wake you up with testing. As different noise levels will wake up folks.
Cup sizes seem smaller than they appear. However, that seems like malarkey. Based on my experience, it’ll brew 5 6-oz cups. I mentioned it as a con to have something for you to keep in mind.
Treat this machine well, though. It’s made of plastic and isn’t as durable as coffee makers with stainless steel bodies. Mr. Coffee needed to cut corners to reduce costs, though. This is where they did it.
Otherwise, the warming plate will keep your coffee hot for up to 60 minutes.
7. BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffeemaker: Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker, Canada
The BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup is a perfect fit for folks with limited counter space or for use in travel trailers. It also operates on 120V plugs, which is great for plug outlets in Canada.
The BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup offers a solid performance at a reasonable price.
It doesn’t have a bunch of fancy features like programming. But it has a reusable filter. Great for saving money on paper filters; but not as much so for preventing finer coffee grounds from getting in your drink.
There’s also the Sneak-a-Cup feature. The coffee maker will stop pouring once you withdraw your cup from the maker. Great for those desperate to get some energy quickly.
The Black+Decker will fit into most kitchens due to its compact size. Unlike most coffee makers, you can see the amount left in the water reservoir at the front of the machine. You won’t need to turn the machine around to see whether it requires a refill.
Tips for Finding the Best 5-Cup Coffee Maker: Buying Guide
Use the following factors to help you build a criterion when shopping for a 5-cup coffee maker:
I’ll cover each factor more in-depth throughout the following sections. I’ll provide examples of what you should consider, and why.
1. Ease of Maintenance
Coffee residue can build up over time, affecting the machine’s performance and the taste of your coffee. Regular maintenance extends the lifespan of your coffee maker, giving you more bang for your buck.
Certain design features make a coffee maker easier to clean and maintain.
Detachable components allow for thorough cleaning in hard-to-reach areas. Dishwasher-safe parts simplify the cleaning process. And a self-cleaning feature automates the descaling process, saving you time and effort.
Many 5-cup coffee makers incorporate these features. They often come with removable filter baskets and carafes that are dishwasher-safe. Some models even include a self-cleaning cycle.
2. Water Tank Capacity & Machine Size
A larger tank suits frequent coffee drinkers or households with multiple coffee lovers—no need for constant refills. Smaller tanks work well for occasional coffee sippers who prefer freshly filled water each time.
Machine size is critical, especially for those with space limitations.
Measure your countertop area first. Small kitchens, tiny homes, and studio apartments may need compact models. Also, look upwards. Some machines need extra vertical clearance as much as 2.5 inches to access top-loaded water tanks.
Water tank and machine sizes for 5-cup coffee makers vary, providing flexibility for different user needs.
3. Programming & Features
Here’s some of what you’ll find when shopping for 5-cup coffee makers:
- Programmable Timer: Enables setting your brewing time in advance.
- Auto Shut-off: Ensures safety and energy conservation when you forget to turn it off.
- Brew Strength Control: Lets you adjust your coffee’s strength to your taste.
- Water Level Indicator: Aids in accurate filling, preventing overflow or weak brews.
- Pause and Serve: Allows you to pour a cup mid-brew without mess or waiting.
High-end coffee makers often house all these features and more. More affordable models will include 1 or 2 of these features. Most 5-cup coffee makers I’ve seen under $200 will usually include a timer and auto-shut-off.
4. Durable Materials & Aesthetics
A machine that breaks down after a few uses will cost you more in replacements. Different materials offer varied benefits and downsides.
Stainless steel is a top choice—it’s sturdy, heat-resistant, and adds a sleek look to your kitchen . However, it can be costly. Plastic is a budget-friendly alternative, though it may not last as long. It’s light, but can warp with heat.
Aesthetic appeal is also important. A good-looking coffee maker can elevate your kitchen decor.
Most 5-cup coffee makers under $70 won’t look good and will have plastic casing. I recommend spending at least $100 to get a stainless steel coffee maker that’ll look better and last longer.
5. Thermal vs. Glass Carafe
Thermal carafes, made from stainless steel or another insulated material, are best for those desiring hot coffee throughout the day.
The pros include:
- Retains heat for longer: Ideal for slow sippers who want hot coffee hours after brewing.
- Resilient design: Less prone to breaking, making it perfect for busy households or offices.
- Improved taste preservation: Limits exposure to air, preserving the coffee’s flavor for extended periods.
Thermal carafes can cost a lot and might not show the amount of coffee left, making it challenging to judge when you need a refill. They can also be heavier than glass carafes, making them less ideal for those with mobility issues or weaker grips.
Glass carafes, typically seen with most coffee makers, are perfect for those who consume their coffee quickly and appreciate visual appeal.
The pros encompass:
- Visual clarity: Easy to see how much coffee remains, ideal for precise brewing.
- Lower cost: More affordable than their thermal counterparts, suiting budget-conscious consumers.
- Lighter weight: Easier to handle and pour, especially for those with strength concerns.
Glass carafes don’t retain heat as well, requiring a hotplate that can overcook the coffee, altering its taste. They’re also more fragile, needing careful handling to prevent breakage.
Whether you choose a 5-cup coffee maker with a thermal or glass carafe largely depends on your specific needs and coffee habits. While many 5-cup coffee makers use glass carafes, options with thermal carafes are also available.
Types of 5-Cup Coffee Makers
Here are different types of 5-cup coffee makers you may encounter:
Here’s who each machine works best for:
- Drip coffee maker: Producing black coffee.
- Thermal coffee maker: Great for keeping coffee hotter for longer.
- Nespresso/K-Cup: Quick, strong-tasting coffee.
- Cold brew maker: Less acidic coffee.
- Stovetop coffee maker: Brewing concentrated coffee for groups of people.
On to frequently asked questions.
FAQs: 5-Cup Coffee Maker
Check out these frequently asked questions surrounding 5-cup coffee makers.
Here are our top 3 choices:
- Zojirushi Zutto: Beginner-friendly & durable.
- Cuisinart DCC-5570 5-Cup Coffeemaker: Easy to use & has a removable water reservoir.
- Krups Simply Brew: Includes various functions while not costing much.
Most machines within this price range don’t look as good or last as long as the Zojirushi Zutto. Hence, why it was my first choice.
* Price will vary by model, manufacturer, and vendor.